Close

What NPRM Comments Reveal About EB-5 Industry and Investor Concerns

463 comments made in response to proposed EB-5 rules highlight where investors, industry groups, Regional Centers, and others believe DHS overstepped its bounds and what areas have improved since the RIA.

“Better late than never” is how one might describe the announcement on July 1st, 2026, of a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) designed to implement and clarify rules from the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 (RIA). The four years it took since the RIA’s passage was a lot longer than the promised 270 days, but at least DHS is trying.

After reading the 358-page document, industry stakeholders were able to offer their opinions during a public comment period. Jill Jones, JTC Head of Specialty Administration and General Counsel – USA, and Mine Ekim, Managing Director, Legal & Head of Investor Experience at Civitas Capital Group, combed through the comments to see where different stakeholder groups agreed, and where they differed, in their views on the proposals in the NPRM.

Their findings about what the comment record reveals can be found in the Fall 2026 Regional Center Business Journal from Invest In the USA (IIUSA), in an article titled, “From Statute to Rule: What the NPRM Comment Record Says About Where EB-5 Stands.” They reviewed 463 published comments from Regional Centers, industry groups, and individuals, some of which were identified as EB-5 investors while others remained anonymous. The comments revealed “a reasonably candid statement of what practitioners and investors actually care about four years into the RIA era.”

Where industry and investors agreed in the comment record

There were several areas of the NPRM on which the commenters largely agreed. Issues like bridge financing and source of funds documentation were mentioned by both industry practitioners and EB-5 investors, many of whom were concerned about the requirement for investors to produce source of funds documentation for a project’s non-EB-5 capital.

“Proposed 8 CFR 204.407(c)(4) would require that the source of all capital invested in the new commercial enterprise or provided to the job-creating entity be identified, documented, and lawful,” say Jones and Ekim. “Commenters from IIUSA to AILA to individual business plan writers made the same point from different angles: an individual investor has no contractual or practical ability to document a construction lender’s balance sheet, and INA 203(b)(5)(L) places the burden on the investor’s own capital.”

In these areas of agreement, one might expect DHS to respond to the consensus and alter or eliminate these provisions. But there’s always the chance for disappointment, and we’ll have to wait for the final rule to see if the comments had any effect.

Where EB-5 stakeholders disagreed in the NPRM comment record

There were other issues on which various stakeholders differed. “These are particularly dangerous,” the authors explain, “because history tells us that where industry stakeholders are divided, the decision makers – legislators and regulators alike – have refused to act.”

These areas include clarification on when the two-year sustainment clock should begin. Investors stated a desire for the sustainment period to “run from the release of capital to the new commercial enterprise, that it not be stretched by draw timing outside their control, and that redeployment not be forced on them after the period ends.” In contrast, “institutional comments approached the same provisions from the opposite direction.”

These differences can be understood as a matter of perspective: investors want the clock to start as early as possible, while Regional Centers do not want to create an unrealistic expectation for returning capital by shortening the required sustainment period. The same could be said on the issue of fund administration waivers: service providers want audits performed in lieu of fund administration to be more comprehensive, while Regional Centers want them to be less burdensome.

That said, fund administration itself was not at issue: “There was general support for the fund administration concept as an anti-fraud/integrity measure, and several comments asking for clarity on the implementation of separate accounts and cosignatory practices. Any disagreement centers on how fund administration works in practice and the requirement’s particulars, not its existence.”

What EB-5 NPRM comments tell us about the state of the program

In their article, Jones and Ekim discuss the wide range of commenters and some surprises in terms of bodies that chose to participate, as well as the provisions that were not commented on. We don’t know what the final rule will entail, but the comment record itself can tell us what stakeholders are most concerned about at this point in the lifespan of the RIA.

“The provisions that drew the most institutional comment were the ones where the NPRM would reverse practice the industry has built on,” say Jones and Ekim. “The industry, in other words, is asking to keep what it has, not to be given something new.”

In general, the industry appears pleased with how the RIA has strengthened integrity requirements and investor protections. “No commenter we reviewed asked DHS to conduct fewer background checks, drop audits, or lower the fund administration requirement,” the article says.

“The RIA promised an EB-5 program that was more secure for investors, more accountable for regional centers, and more predictable for everyone. The NPRM goes a long way toward delivering that by codifying four years of practice.”

As we await the final rule, the industry will continue moving toward a series of deadlines: the November 2026 increase in filing fees, the January 2027 increase in minimum investment amounts, and the September 2027 reauthorization deadline for the EB-5 Regional Center Program. The NPRM, and the responses to it, indicate a strengthening industry that is serious about its future. Click the button below to learn more about the NPRM and what it indicates about EB-5’s future.

The NPRM and USCIS Priorities

Preparing for the EB-5 final rule?

JTC’s EB-5 specialists can help you plan for what the proposed changes may mean for your project.

Preparing for the EB-5 final rule?

JTC’s EB-5 specialists can help you plan for what the proposed changes may mean for your project.

Stay Connected

Stay up to date with expert insights, latest updates and exclusive content.

Let’s Bring Your Vision to Life

From 2,500 employee owners to 14,000+ clients, our journey is marked by stability and success.